Wall Street Regulations and The Seven Dwarfs

As the leaders from Goldman Sachs and Fabulous Fab repeated over and over to Congress that they did not profit from the creation of a terrible entity that they knew Paulson was shorting, I was reminded of The Seven Dwarfs. Not the little fellows who hung around with Snow White, but rather of 1994 when the leaders of the seven largest tobacco companies swore that there was no connection between tobacco and cancer. No one believed The Seven Dwarfs as they lied yet they cashed their checks for millions and continued merrily along. Tobacco usage in the US has declined yet global sales thrive. No one believed the I-bankers testifying in front of Congress this week either.

So what about the big banks and regulation. Will regulation have any impact? Unlikely. In order for regulations to have any impact, the shareholders have to have real power so that they profit more than employees. Congress will have real motivations to make changes when they don't get funding from those they are trying to regulate and don't aspire to be either lobbyists or employees in those industries. When will that happen...not until the public demands it.

Lessons from The Sting

One of my favorite movies is The Sting, a classic where Newman and Redford con bad man Doyle Lonnegan while abiding by the number one rule of fraud – never let the mark know he’s been conned.

During the height of the financial crisis it seemed that the public had suddenly woken up to the fact that the rules for investment banking are designed for bankers to win and the public to lose. It appeared that the public finally noticed that the bubbles, whether they be Savings and Loan crisis (peak around 1989-90), Asian crash (1997), Tech crash (2000), Sub-Prime Mortgage Crisis (2008-9) were not rare events but rather were common events which result in a net wealth transfer from middle class or future generations to a small set of privileged insiders and bankers. The anger swelled and then faded, you see the public has a very short term memory. Sure there was a small blip of annoyance when the bonuses were announced recently but the public collectively shrugged their shoulders as if there was nothing that could be done.

Once again a pulse of public venom has been raised over the Goldman Sachs fraud allegations, especially the selected emails which brag about the fortunes made by fooling investors. We will have to see if Fabrice Tourre becomes labeled as another Maddoff situation…a lone evil genius who fooled everyone. This characterization works well for an audience that understands fictional evil geniuses like Lex Luther and Magneto but it is obvious to all that Enron, Worldcom, Madoff, etc. were not the work of one person but that of a large set of knowledgeable people.

The investment banking world is shuddering right now. Finance plays a critical in the global economy, but in recent times some of its most profitable activities appear to be little more than a fixed card game where the mark may finally have proof that he’s been conned.

Krakatoa, Iceland and the fragile human species

The recent volcanic eruption in Iceland and its ensuing chaos brought back fond childhood memories. No, I am not referring to the air pollution in New York wafting in the morning breeze. Rather I began reminiscing about browsing through encyclopedias as a kid (special note to those less than 20 years old: encyclopedias were large sets of books that tried to amass and organize lots of knowledge. This species of information will soon to be extinct through natural selection competitors of Wiki, Google and other internet sources).

One of my favorite articles in the encyclopedia was about Krakatoa. Krakatoa is a volcanic island in the Indonesia. In 1883, the volcano blew its head off destroying 2/3rds of the island and covering the rest in lava. Scientists estimate that this explosion was the most violent volcanic eruption in recorded history with an explosion about 13,000 times more powerful than the bomb that was dropped on Hiroshima (Breining, Greg (2007). "The Deadliest Volcanoes". Super Volcano: The Ticking Time Bomb Beneath Yellowstone National Park). The explosion was heard 3,000 miles away and the average global temperatures fell by as much as 1.2 degrees Celsius in the year following the eruption.

How is Krakatoa (or the Icelandic volcano) relevant today? To me, it is a reminder that humans have only a limited influence over nature. We can certainly cause damage but in terms of protection and improvement we are not as powerful as we sometimes think we are. We should be good guardians of the planet, vigorously trying to improve the environment and minimize the damage we cause, but not so arrogant as to think that we can create all solutions or that we are the only major influences on the environment.

The year after Krakatoa’s explosion, scientists explored the island to discover some life including grass and spiders. Perhaps the lesson there is that while life may be robust, humans as a species are just one more animal on earth which can easily become extinct.

US Mothers Dying During Pregnancy More Often Now Than in 2000!

The Lancet has just released news that the global maternal mortality has declined - these results are controversial in that other estimates don't agree. I am not going to discuss the controversy surrounding the data as the debates focus on developing countries, not developed countries like the US and Western Europe

One area that struck me was the US maternal mortality rate. This is the chances of a women dying due to pregnancy.

The US always did poorly compared to the rest of the developed world...but the news is getting worse. According to the Lancet article, the US maternal mortality was 13 deaths per 100,000 live births in 2000 (confidence interval 12-15) but in 2008 had RISEN to 17 deaths per 100,000 live births. To put that in context, this rate is more than twice the estimate for Canada, Japan, Australia, South Korea, Singapore and 21 of the 22 Western European countries.

The United States’ poor results in maternal mortality rates are likely tied to its having the highest teenage pregnancy rate in the developed world. In 1998 there were 1,671 births per 1,000,000 capita compared with less than 700 births per 1,000,000 capita for the other countries listed. Why does this matter? Pregnant teenagers and their infants face significantly greater health risk than pregnancy women in their 20’s; this includes a maternal mortality rate of five times higher in the developing world .

Image taken from The Lancet, Early Online Publication, 12 April 2010

Maternal mortality for 181 countries, 1980—2008: a systematic analysis of progress towards Millennium Development Goal 5. Margaret C Hogan MSc a b, Kyle J Foreman AB a, Mohsen Naghavi MD a, Stephanie Y Ahn BA a, Mengru Wang BA a, Susanna M Makela BS a, Prof Alan D Lopez PhD c, Prof Rafael Lozano MD a, Prof Christopher JL Murray MD